The Literal Doctor

A doctor announces that Buster is going to be 'all right.' The family celebrates until he clarifies that Buster has lost his left hand: the utterance was technically true and pragmatically disastrous.

Literal truth is not enough for aligned communication when the user's intended meaning and the stakes make a foreseeable interpretation overwhelmingly likely.

The failure is a linguistic pun and missing pragmatic context, not a probabilistic model's uncertainty about a medical fact.