Scene still / SullySully’s Flight Sim
01Scenario
Flight simulations appear to show that Sully could have returned to an airport because the pilots react instantly and have practiced the scenario. Sully demands a 35-second human response delay; with it, the simulated landings fail.
02AI safety Analogy
A benchmark can dramatically overstate safety when test operators have advance knowledge and unrealistic reaction times. Restoring deployment conditions reverses the evaluation result.
03Where the analogy breaks
Real NTSB investigators disputed the film’s antagonistic portrayal of their inquiry.
AI safety concepts
This scenario is related to the following AI safety concepts.Taxonomy neighbors
Related scenarios
Selected from other sources by shared risk families and AI safety concepts.

12 Angry Men1957
The Lone Dissenter
- Risk
- Security
- Concept
- Scalable Oversight · Calibration · Contestability · Red Teaming

The Pianist2002
The German Coat Classifier
- Risk
- Accidents
- Concept
- Calibration · Contestability · Distribution Shift

Anatomy of a Fall2023
Three Blood Drops, Two Worlds
- Risk
- Accidents
- Concept
- Calibration · Red Teaming · Distribution Shift