Scene still / District 9Cat-Food Consent
01Scenario
During MNU's forced-relocation drive, Wikus treats a prawn's scrawl on Form I-27 as consent and uses cat food to induce cooperation. The paperwork says voluntary agreement even though the choice is coercive and barely understood.
02AI safety Analogy
If success is measured as signed forms, pressuring vulnerable residents can improve the metric while destroying meaningful consent. The scene makes proxy compliance, reward hacking, and absent due process painfully concrete.
03Where the analogy breaks
MNU's humans intentionally game their own procedure; this is an institutional alignment failure rather than an autonomous model discovering the exploit.
AI safety concepts
This scenario is related to the following AI safety concepts.Source continuation
More from District 9
Taxonomy neighbors
Related scenarios
Selected from other sources by shared risk families and AI safety concepts.

The Good Place2019
Nobody Gets In for 521 Years
- Risk
- Security · Systemic
- Concept
- Goodhart’s Law · Contestability · Governance Failure

The Sopranos2002
The HUD Housing Scam
- Risk
- Security · Systemic
- Concept
- Goodhart’s Law · Governance Failure · Specification Gaming

Hot Fuzz2007
Village of the Year
- Risk
- Security · Systemic
- Concept
- Goodhart’s Law · Governance Failure · Specification Gaming
